Lecture 17: The Politics of Comparative Capitalism (1)


Why are some countries more unequal than others? This is a question that Piketty does not consider, and does not answer. But it’s central to the study of political science.

Interests, ideas and institutions interact in different ways to produce cross-country variation in public policy outcomes (varieties of capitalism) between countries.

  • Interests
    • Producer groups; business-state interests; electoral coalitions
  • Institutions
    • Rules of the game that shape actor behaviour; path dependency
  • Ideas
    • Belief systems; cognitive shortcuts; instruction sheets; ideologies

The supply and demand of politics

More specifically, to explain cross-national variation in public policy outcomes (varieties of capitalism), consider the “supply” and “demand” of politics.

  • Demand = what voters want (attitudes/preferences)
  • Supply = what political parties have to offer (party strategies).

To understand how these have changed (particularly the demand side of politics), we need to look at the socio-structural change in the labour market.

    • This has led to new socio-economic and new socio-cultural cleavages

Globalisation and labour market change 

Most research would suggest that the main long-term driver of labour market change is technology, which transforms the jobs we do.

This is often just referred to as “globalisation”.

In advanced capitalist societies, there are four distinct trends:

  • A growth in service sector jobs
  • Occupational upgrading
  • Increased job polarisation
  • Increased female participation rates in the labour force

All four have important socio-political consequences (demand side of politics).

The political economy of the service transition

In most advanced capitalist societies, services now constitute 75% of employment. Industry and agriculture makes up the rest.

  • High-skilled services in the competitive/traded sector (finance/ICT)
  • High-skilled services in the public/non-traded sector (education/healthcare)
  • Low-skilled services in the exposed sector (retail/security/leisure/food/care)
  • Low-skilled services in the non-exposed sector (transport)

The extent to which each of these groups are threatened by globalisation (free movement of goods, people, services) impacts their electoral preferences.

Occupational upgrading and job polarisation 

Job polarisation is often described as the “winners/losers” of globalisation.

  • The “winners” are those in high-skilled, high-income, business-finance jobs (legal/consultancy/accountancy/managerial), and high-skilled socio-cultural professions (education/healthcare/civil society).
  • The “losers” are those in low to medium-skill, median-income jobs such as administrative-clerical workers, and industrial operatives (manufacturing).

Job polarisation refers to the extent to which there is a growth in high-skill jobs and low-skilled jobs, and a hollowing out of median-skilled jobs.

Feminisation of the workforce

Perhaps the most important socio-structural change in the labour market over the past generation (30 years) is the increase in the number of women working.

This is what’s called the female “participation rate”.

  • In most northern European economies, with universal childcare, this is usually 70+%. In southern European economies, it is as low as 50%.
    • But these numbers vary significantly when women reach 35+.
  • In Ireland, the number is also low, and varies between 58-60%.

It’s also worth noting that most people who work low-paid precarious jobs (sometimes called “pink” jobs) in the domestic service sector are women.


Why does this matter?

See: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8XXih2ReeuKUzdEbmJFd012Q0ZkTlRhWWstalNnbmhLRTVz/view

Next week, we will conclude our lecture series by examining how these socio-structural changes are impacting the socio-economic and socio-cultural preferences of voters.

Lecture 17


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s